Showing posts with label critics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label critics. Show all posts

Thursday, July 15, 2010

Consequences

A good friend of mine has taken to heavily criticizing President Barack Obama on her Facebook page, torn the Obama sticker from her car and coined the phrase, "Blowbama," which is funny. Her opinion is that the BP killing of the Gulf is so critical to our species that Obama should have quit everything and moved his operations down to Louisiana, focusing almost exclusively on fixing the hole. When I challenged her on it she claimed that from the five major news sources she reads everyday, he didn't seem to be doing anything else.

This is where I wrote:
Clearly not true that it's the only thing that matters. He's about to pass a form of financial reform (that the GOP is already campaigning to repeal), dealing with Afghanistan, North Korea, Mideast Peace, trying to get unemployment extensions passed (which the GOP is opposing), trying to get more stimulus (which the GOP...you get the idea), working on an overall climate bill, G20 meeting, nominating and shepherding a Supreme Court nominee, passing PTSD benefits for veterans, plus whatever threats and future projects that we do not yet know about are going on.

If you're reading those five sources and not seeing at least some of this, I question the sources or what you're focusing on.

You need to get off your Obama-hate. There's a Tea Party for that. Fine to try on influence/pressure him, that's a good thing to do, but this type of thinking is what got Ralph Nader his support in 2000 and led to 8 ruinous years of George Bush...that Obama is still trying to dig the country out of.

(And added:)

He did get a team of scientists together, perhaps why the cap today. And he's being criticized from the right for the group he put together to study BP fault and report - no oil industry flacks on it!

Since the time I wrote this the financial reform bill, whether you think it goes far enough or not (or are a Republican opposed for those political or ideological reasons to any such regulation at all) has passed the Senate. The BP lesion has been capped and the President has rightly pointed out that, while good news, there is so much more ahead, the problem is far from over thanks to the mega-damage done. And it might leak again.

However, elections have consequences and here's what you get if you keep taking the anti-Obama side, keep Dem enthusiasm low for November and let the GOP take the House or Senate - per Paul Krugman, who hasn't been shy about criticizing the current Administration himself:
Republicans are feeling good about the midterms — so good that they’ve started saying what they really think. This week the party’s Senate leadership stopped pretending that it cares about deficits, stating explicitly that while we can’t afford to aid the unemployed or prevent mass layoffs of schoolteachers, cost is literally no object when it comes to tax cuts for the affluent.

And that’s one reason — there are others — why you should fear the consequences if the G.O.P. actually does as well in November as it hopes.
...

But this past Monday Jon Kyl of Arizona, the second-ranking Republican in the Senate, was asked the obvious question: if deficits are so worrisome, what about the budgetary cost of extending the Bush tax cuts for the wealthy, which the Obama administration wants to let expire but Republicans want to make permanent? What should replace $650 billion or more in lost revenue over the next decade?

His answer was breathtaking: “You do need to offset the cost of increased spending. And that’s what Republicans object to. But you should never have to offset the cost of a deliberate decision to reduce tax rates on Americans.” So $30 billion in aid to the unemployed is unaffordable, but 20 times that much in tax cuts for the rich doesn’t count.

...

Of course, flirting with crisis is arguably part of the plan. There has always been a sense in which voodoo economics was a cover story for the real doctrine, which was “starve the beast”: slash revenue with tax cuts, then demand spending cuts to close the resulting budget gap. The point is that starve the beast basically amounts to deliberately creating a fiscal crisis, in the belief that the crisis can be used to push through unpopular policies, like dismantling Social Security.


And this -- remember the Clinton years of GOP noise, misdirection and obstruction:

Republican Rep. Darrell Issa of California has hounded President Obama all year about the apparent job offers the White House made to certain Democratic Senate candidates this election season -- and if Republicans win control of the House this November, Issa intends to significantly ratchet up his inquiries into what he sees as potential administration wrongdoing.

As the top Republican on the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee, Issa would become chairman of the committee if Republicans managed to win the majority this fall. If he became chairman, Issa has said he would double his staff from 40 to between 70 and 80, Politico reports. As chairman, he would also have the power to subpoena White House officials to appear before the committee under oath.


Here's their plan to curtail regulations. Here's their new Tea Party Caucus in Congress itself, led by Rep. Michele Bachmann (R-MN). Here's how the GOP (along with a few Blue Dog Dems) are obstructing economic stimulus to keep us from falling deeper again.

So when I read this Blowbama stuff, I just ask that everyone remember, this kind of thinking is what got Ralph Nader enough votes to keep Al Gore from becoming President, opening the door for eight-count-'em-eight years of George Bush, an unprovoked war against Iraq, economic collapse and the relaxation of energy regulations (thanks to Dick Cheney) that brought us the Gulf.

So if Obama isn't the progressive demigod who would likely end up a Jimmy Carter and end up less effective than he is by following the type of "camp out in the Gulf" directives above, if you didn't follow his campaign and learn that he's more of a conservative-progressive, no-drama, not the scary black man President that the Tea Partiers still believe is driving us to a socialist-fascist slave state, then you're missing the point of how politics really works. With everything that Obama is up against, his list of achievements thus far is astonishing.

I guarantee that once Obama is out of office, whether in two years or six, just as with Bill Clinton those on the Left who complain about him now will look back with fondness and think about how much of a better direction this country was moving in before President Huckabee or Gingrich or Daniels or Thune or Pawlenty or Romney.

Or President Palin.

Friday, August 21, 2009

The Transcended Film Critic

I was fortunate enough to meet Roger Ebert several years ago atop Nob Hill in San Francisco, a few hours after he co-hosted an advertising award event at the Masonic Center. He was still in his tux and I was with the friend who brought me to the event, and when we stopped to congratulate him on a good job, he immediately turned the conversation to the quality of some of the work shown and, like a bunch of film fans meeting on a street corner, we traded lively views on our favorite spots.

Ebert is the best of the mainstream film critics because he's a populist epicurean, which is to say a popularizer of quality films both contemporary and classic. His Overlooked Film Festival (now called Ebertfest) is always brilliantly curated, and the Great Movies section of his website is full of fascinating gems of classic film descriptions and advocacy.

Every since being diagnosed with cancer and undergoing very difficult surgery, Ebert has been in a long, slow recovery. But he hasn't given up. It surely feels like a second life for him, considering that his partner in the iconic At the Movies show, Gene Siskel, didn't survive the disease. And now he's speaking out on the Obama health plan (in so much as Obama's principles for health care/health insurance reform are influencing the House and developing Senate bills).

He's making the moral case for this much-needed reform.

And he's not afraid to call elements of the plan socialism, because as he writes:
Readers have written about their belief in Federalism, Free Market Capitalism, strict Constitutionalism, personal liberty, Libertarianism, and so on. To one of these readers I wrote something like: "Do you think your views on federalism will be of much interest to unemployed wage-earners unable to obtain coverage for their families?" To another, I wrote: "I hope your philosophy will be of comfort if you develop a serious illness."
As I've said for awhile, the biggest problem with American Republicanism/Conservatism as it exists today is the theoretical nature of all the rhetoric. Nothing is based in hard evidence -- we weren't greeted as liberators in Iraq, we didn't bolster the economy with Bush's tax cuts for the rich, Creationism is not the practical equivalent of Darwinism, and even those who complain about certain health services in Canada and England do not, by and large, wish for a re-privatized system.

Thanks, Roger. I hope you live long enough to see this country implement a public health insurance option that keeps the private companies honest, and a system where when someone loses their job thanks to a high-level corporate cost-cutting decision made by hyper-rich CEOS and SVPs, their family won't suddenly be without proper health care.

Especially if something goes wrong.

Like getting cancer.

Thursday, October 18, 2007

Elegy for an Assassin

I made a point of hitting a movie theater last night to see The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford last night before it vanished from those screens. As a major studio release it seemed doomed to failure by title as well as length, two hours and forty minutes. There were five to eight walk-outs last night (I think the first three had slipped in after another movie) and maybe twenty of us left when the credits rolled.

Critical reaction has generally been polarized, but fervent supporters include the legendary Andrew Sarris and a number of other more contemporary critics I can usually trust. It hasn't been a priority movie for any of my friends, even the Deadwood lovers, so I ended up going alone.

Even an acronym for the title seems too long, TAOJJBTCRF, so with your forbearance I'll just call it The Assassination.

The Assassination is nominally a Western, but it's actually in the "History as Fever Dream" genre dominated by Terrence Malick, most similarly in Days of Heaven and The New World. Robert Altman's McCabe and Mrs. Miller is an obvious antecedent and Ridley Scott's Blade Runner (interestingly enough, also one of Assassination's producers) is a future version of this genre. Stanley Kubrick's Barry Lyndon also comes to mind, with a similar narration style although Kubrick's was a turn or two more ironic.

In lesser hands this kind of epic can fall flat, whether or not a studio messes with the cut. In the right hands, the right minds, you're not bored by the length because the filmmaker is just adjusting the pace to the times of the story, to give you a feeling of living in those spaces, those old wooden rooms, those open fields of grain and dust, to give you essentially a time travel experience.

This is the promise of the dawn of cinema. The senses enveloped, the spectator transported -- not pummeled, not ridden -- to a sociologically alien environment where men and women make different decisions than they would today, where the choices are bleakly different. History as hallucination. History as an anxious landscape, a place just barely safe enough to visit in the theater, a place you and I would want to escape to and then from. History as a seductive dream from which we are trying to awake.

The length of the movie is its vividness, its life "in the moment" whether a rolling cloud transition or a chilly evening's chat on the front porch. As is typical for movies this length, there are four acts instead of the usual three, with the first act acting as prologue: think the half hour wedding sequence opening The Godfather. The plot doesn't really begin until Sonny opens his big mouth at a meeting, but what an extended movie prologue does it to double the amount of time for planting, laying in characters and motifs that will pay off bigger in the end for enriching our involvement.

So the first forty minutes of The Assassination is prologue establishing first Jesse James in 1881, heading into his last train robbery with his older brother, Frank, both of them aware this is the end of the line, and then showing us how Robert Ford insinuates himself into the gang on the eve of the crime. Ford is the youngest of five brothers, not yet 20, and he's grown up worshiping the image of James from the dime novels he keeps hidden under his bed. We establish James' brutality. Jesse asks of Ford, "Do you want to be like me? Or do you want to BE me?"

The meat of the movie, the crisis that runs through the second and third act (i.e. 1st and 2nd act, post-prologue) is a slow-burn distillation of the segment in Goodfellas where DeNiro's character is wiping out the heist gang one-by-one. Jesse thinks he's going to be betrayed and thus ends up insuring it. Brad Pitt does a brilliant job, playing Jesse James like a rattlesnake, eyeing you suspiciously and ready to strike at any moment, unpredictably, mesmerizingly. He hits the highs and lows of Jesse's manic depression. In the most terrifying scene, he brutalizes a teenage boy without allowing him to speak, even to give him the information he wants. (Shades of Guantanamo.)

Casey Affleck is equally brilliant, taking perhaps even bigger risks, playing Robert Ford as Mark David Chapman, an ultimate fan who loses his identity in his idol, is rebuffed, and then comes back a new and deadlier man. Ford isn't stupid so much as he's clueless, an innocent who learns he needs clues, which lead him to an ultimately ignominious fate, extraordinary in how it unfolds (the final act, a fourth that plays like a traditional third).

I found myself constantly in the thrall of the movie, a world that for its more measured pace is no less lethal than ours if not moreso. It's the anxious version of a John Ford historical western, a Liberty Valance or My Darling Clementine on a hair-trigger. For all the open vistas, when the men in the longcoats approach the house with rifles there's no place to run. When the bandits rob the train they shower the air with gunfire, pop-pop-popping away recklessly until the passengers are cowed, and then starting up again just when nerves have settled.

It's also a land of scarcity. Less people, less money, less food. Two-story housing developments on a hill in the middle of nowhere. Tense journeys through the wilderness. Stark codes of behavior even among thieves.

The lensing, by longtime Coen Brothers cinematographer, Roger Deakens, is superb, Oscar material. The supporting cast performs brilliantly, capturing nuances of class and intelligence, just what exactly such endeavors would attract, most notably Sam Rockwell as brother Charlie Ford, the iconographic Sam Shepard, now with sagging eyelids to match his long mustache, Deadwood's Garret Dillahunt and Paul Schneider as other gang members. Mary-Louise Parker in a sort of high-class cameo plays Zee James, Jesse's wife, and while her lines are few, she makes the most of her biggest moment. Nick Cave leads the scoring and appears as a Bowery saloon minstrel, again with the same preternatural understanding of darkest Western history that he provided to The Proposition. All of this is tribute to New Zealand-born director/screenwriter Andrew Dominik, who's only previous film credit is Chopper, another criminal character study and the movie that introduced Eric Bana to the world.

Only in the last act, the last ten minutes of the movie slipping through your fingers like the final pages of an enrapturing novel, do we learn why the movie's title is so accurate. This is history writ large in the typeface of the era. This is epic made sharp and cutting by sociology. This is a movie that you live in for two and two-thirds hours so it can live in you indefinitely, sharpening its questions as you turn it like a bauble in your hand.

There's only one other recent release I can think of in its class, this kind of adult epic American storytelling in the vivid ribbon of dreams form, and that's David Fincher's Zodiac. It's another film that did not find its audience the first time on the big screen, one that would benefit for an old-fashioned movie revival house system, but hopefully now with DVD. Another very adult film about men and the temperature of their souls, told through their fluctuations moment-to-moment, yet over a grand and inevitable landscape.

There's a central image in The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford that recurs throughout the picture, that of the chair. In a moment of suburban respite, Jesse sits in a dining room chair set out in a backyard of overgrown, wheat-like grass. He proffers snakes like Cleopatra, live and as food. That chair is his throne and he is kingly in bearing, the kingly sociopath. With no television, no telephone, the chairs are where you sat and talked, hour after hour, and when we see an empty chair that Jesse has inhabited, there in a spartan room, we still feel his presence. Somebody has sat there, a number of others over time, the chain enduring without pity but their ghosts left behind by the furniture as reminder.

It's the sweet yearning of history. All that we witnessed. All that we missed.

All that is long gone, forever.

Wednesday, July 18, 2007

Since Dickens

When I was in high school reading Great Expectations by superstar 19th Century novelist Charles Dickens for the first or second time (9th Grade + 12th), as we got wrapped up in Pip, Estrella and Miss Havisham, I remember hearing a few times about how Dickens wrote in serialized form, and in a kind of height of the printed word distribution technology, people would read the chapters as soon as they came out.

The anticipation surrounding the final chapters of The Old Curiosity Shop, and the fate of the ill-starred girl at the center of it, was unprecedented:
In January 1841, passengers arriving in New York from Europe would be greeted by anxious people on the docks. They all had the same question: "Is Little Nell dead?" Such was the hysteria created by Charles Dickens' novel The Old Curiosity Shop.

Back then, of course, consuming media meant reading, but today that activity is for the minority of media consumers. Except for this:
Copies of the final Harry Potter book have already been shipped to customers by one U.S. online retailer, U.S. publisher Scholastic said on Wednesday, and purported copies of the novel have flooded the Internet...

...Photographs have also been posted on the Internet of what is claimed to be each page of the book, but Scholastic would not comment on whether they were real. Links to the pictures quickly flooded Web sites around the world...

...Rowling fueled speculation about the ending of the last book when she said last year that at least two characters would be killed off and a third got a reprieve.

Tight security has surrounded Rowling's eagerly awaited final novel about the teenage wizard. The first six books have sold 325 million copies worldwide.

Potter fans reacted angrily to purported Internet leaks...


So many people are so passionate about a book?

Has my whole world turned upside down?

I'm reading about literary authority Harold Bloom getting his panties in a knot because kids are reading Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows instead of The Wind in the Willows. For his information, the latter bored both my kids, no matter how much I loved it in 1964. However, I'm up to Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire with my 7-year-old, and we're having a grand time.

(Personal favorite character: Sirius Black, and not just because Gary "Sid Vicious" Oldman portrays him in the moveeeez.)

I'm sure I'll get spoiled by spoilers before my son and I work our way through the next two books and several thousand pages to even start this final volume but who cares, it's amazing that people are going so nuts for a plain ol' epic story, one told with style, intelligent character development, and imagination by a caring author.

Notoriously tough New York Times critic Michiko Kakutani summarizes this book and the series in her thoughtful review today:
The world of Harry Potter is a place where the mundane and the marvelous, the ordinary and the surreal coexist. It’s a place where cars can fly and owls can deliver the mail, a place where paintings talk and a mirror reflects people’s innermost desires. It’s also a place utterly recognizable to readers, a place where death and the catastrophes of daily life are inevitable, and people’s lives are defined by love and loss and hope — the same way they are in our own mortal world.

Congratulations, Ms. Rowling, on an epic achievement. Enjoy this time of glory and the loooong tail to follow.

But most of all, good luck and godspeed on your next creative adventure.